Brotherhood - America's Oldest Winery, Washingtonville

3.9
#16 of 169 in Wineries in New York State
Brotherhood - America's Oldest Winery is located in Washingtonville. To visit Brotherhood - America's Oldest Winery on your trip to Washingtonville, use our Washingtonville holiday planning tool .
Create an itinerary including Brotherhood - America's Oldest Winery
map
Brotherhood - America's Oldest Winery Reviews
Rate this attraction
TripAdvisor Traveler Rating
TripAdvisor Traveler Rating 4.0
283 reviews
Google
4.4
TripAdvisor
  • Family went to the winery on Sunday 10/29/17. It was a very rainy day so all outdoor activities were non existent. Was there 10 years ago and enjoyed touring the outer lands and buildings. It was very...  more »
  • For a small local winery (small being relative to major California wineries), this is an impressive winery with a great selection of wines. Our experience at most wineries in the North East is that th...  more »
  • We went to the Brotherhood winery not really knowing what to expect. It's a bit hard to find, and out of the way by worth it. We chose the wine tour and tasting, It was $10 per person. Our tour guide ...  more »
Google
  • This is The Oldest winery in America and is a great place for a day trip from Manhattan. It's only a bit over an hour drive from midtown Manhattan. We really enjoyed the tour with wine tasting. Our tour guide was knowledgeable on wine as well as the history of the winery and she would tell you some fun facts about the place. As for tasting, we've tried a few red, white, rose and Champagne!! This place is also good for weddings!!
  • We went for the tasting and tour and loved it! The tour was pretty neat since they take you underground to the cellars. The tasting was pretty cheap for 5 full glasses of wine that you get to choose from a list. They even provide crackers. We ended up buying desert wines, carpe diem. Delicious!!
  • Wonderful tour through the cellars with fun facts and great information. Excellent tastings with knowledgeable staff. Nice selection of wines for any price range.
  • Really enjoyed my experienced here. Jeane, one of the tour guides was great. Tasting and a touch for 10 bucks. I don't think you can beat that. They even give you a wine glass as a suvenier. Everybody was very friendly. The with each is very well priced. The town is cozy. Then there is the restaurant. No many options, simple but good. I really liked my food. I'll be coming back
  • Would love to give them a few more stars. First time I went for a tasting, had such an amazing experience and tried so many different wines. We ended up buying a whole bunch of bottles. I went again today for a tasting, and they said no they're not doing them at this point. So instead of buying a whole bunch of bottles, I only bought a few that I could remember what I liked. I understand that closing is at 5 and I got there 435, but there was still another tasting going on, and there were still people buying wine. I would have liked a website that specifically said tasting until 430pm or 4 pm, if you need to stop earlier (it clearly states specific times for tours) . Maybe next time I go, Ill have a better experience. Maybe brotherhood winery will make it specific that tastings end at a certain time, so that i don't leave one winery to make it there to get turned away. Very disappointing since this winery is not near any other wineries and is out of the way. Please change.. and my stars will change as well.

Plan your trip to Washingtonville

  • Get a personalized plan

    A complete day-by-day itinerary
    based on your preferences
  • Customize it

    Refine your plan. We'll find the
    best routes and schedules
  • Book it

    Choose from the best hotels
    and activities. Up to 50% off
  • Manage it

    Everything in one place.
    Everyone on the same page.

Where to stay in Washingtonville

Browse hotels, guesthouses, and unique homes and book your stay on the world's leading accommodation sites.
Live like a local, find unique places to stay
Millions of travel reviews on TripAdvisor

Plans in New York State by other users

4 days in New York City BY A USER FROM UNITED STATES December, popular PREFERENCES: December ATTRACTION STYLE: Popular PACE: Medium 4 days in Ellicottville BY A USER FROM UNITED STATES February, popular PREFERENCES: February ATTRACTION STYLE: Popular PACE: Medium 3 days in New York City BY A USER FROM UNITED STATES December, popular & hidden gems PREFERENCES: December ATTRACTION STYLE: Popular & hidden gems PACE: Medium 21 days in United States BY A USER FROM ARGENTINA December, culture, outdoors, relaxing, beaches, museums, shopping, wildlife, popular PREFERENCES: December, culture, outdoors, relaxing, beaches, museums, shopping, wildlife ATTRACTION STYLE: Popular PACE: Medium 4 days in New York City BY A USER FROM UNITED STATES December, popular PREFERENCES: December ATTRACTION STYLE: Popular PACE: Medium 4 days in New York City BY A USER FROM UNITED STATES December, slow & easy, popular PREFERENCES: December ATTRACTION STYLE: Popular PACE: Slow & easy 1 day in Hunter BY A USER FROM UNITED STATES January, popular PREFERENCES: January ATTRACTION STYLE: Popular PACE: Medium 8 days in United States BY A USER FROM UNITED STATES December, popular PREFERENCES: December ATTRACTION STYLE: Popular PACE: Medium 22 days in United States, Toronto & Niagara Falls BY A USER FROM UNITED KINGDOM September, popular PREFERENCES: September ATTRACTION STYLE: Popular PACE: Medium 6 days in New York City BY A USER FROM SINT MAARTEN (DUTCH PART) October, culture, outdoors, relaxing, historic sites, museums, shopping, hidden gems PREFERENCES: October, culture, outdoors, relaxing, historic sites, museums, shopping ATTRACTION STYLE: Hidden gems PACE: Medium 24 days in United States BY A USER FROM SWEDEN July, culture, outdoors, relaxing, beaches, historic sites, museums, shopping, wildlife, popular PREFERENCES: July, culture, outdoors, relaxing, beaches, historic sites, museums, shopping, wildlife ATTRACTION STYLE: Popular PACE: Medium 7 days in United States BY A USER FROM HONDURAS January, popular PREFERENCES: January ATTRACTION STYLE: Popular PACE: Medium
View more plans