Door County Creamery, Sister Bay

4.7
#2 of 9 in Things to do in Sister Bay
Door County Creamery is located in Sister Bay. Use our Sister Bay travel planner to visit Door County Creamery on your trip to Sister Bay, and learn what else travelers and our writers recommend seeing nearby.
Create an itinerary including Door County Creamery
map
Door County Creamery Reviews
Rate this attraction
TripAdvisor Traveler Rating
TripAdvisor Traveler Rating 5.0
167 reviews
Google
4.6
TripAdvisor
  • Went to see what's inside. In appearance it is pretty beautiful, but once the staff heard that we Russians began a strange behavior. From us pulled back and began to whisper behind his back. Deliriously not nice. Eventually we waited near the cashier though someone 15 minutes, turned around and left. Elsewhere we met very benevolently, but here is. .. In life there is no longer a visit.
    View original
  • Door County Creamery deserves it's number one rating on TripAdvisor for places to eat in Sister Bay. It is a must stop for us when we visit Door County. They have a wonderful selection of fresh meats,...  more »
  • This is a must visit place for my wife and I whenever we are in Door County. Great Chevre and goat feta cheese. Sandwiches, salads and soup are artisan. Soup is exceptional. Good wine selection.  more »
Google
  • Door County Creamery is one of the best little one stop shops for cheese, ice cream, dips, and cream cheeses. They have an assortment of wine and beer as well. Overall you won't be displeased, go in and try what they have to offer. I discovered a local cider company when going here.
  • Do not miss the farm tour!! Even if you don't like goat milk try the gelato. Seriously the best I've ever had!! I would make the trek back just to eat here again - lunch was amazing, and is included with the farm tour, so worth it!
  • Our guide and the goats were great. The products sold here are also delicious. The owner, however, was rude and passive aggressive throughout the tour. She was stingy with samples (scolding a man for asking for a second piece of cheddar and skipping my son when coming around with samples). It was very disheartening given the price of the tour and what could have otherwise been a good experience. I would not recommend the tour but maybe to buy some of their products.
  • More than just ice cream! Food portions are large and delicious. The ice cream is untraditional, with flavors like yogurt and berries, tiramisu, olive oil and sea salt, and strawberry sorbet to name a few. The ice cream was delicious. The cashier was as cold as the ice cream but the shop was inviting. Cheese samples to try as well.
  • This place makes everything to order. The BLT was one of the BEST BLTs I’ve ever had in my entire life. The gelato is amazing too! Must come here!!!

Plan your trip to Sister Bay

  • Get a personalized plan

    A complete day-by-day itinerary
    based on your preferences
  • Customize it

    Refine your plan. We'll find the
    best routes and schedules
  • Book it

    Choose from the best hotels
    and activities. Up to 50% off
  • Manage it

    Everything in one place.
    Everyone on the same page.

Where to stay in Sister Bay

Browse hotels, guesthouses, and unique homes and book your stay on the world's leading accommodation sites.
Live like a local, find unique places to stay
Millions of travel reviews on TripAdvisor

Plans in Sister Bay by other users

4 days in Door County BY A USER FROM UNITED STATES March, outdoors, relaxing, romantic, beaches, shopping, wildlife, popular PREFERENCES: March, outdoors, relaxing, romantic, beaches, shopping, wildlife ATTRACTION STYLE: Popular PACE: Medium 4 days in Door County BY A USER FROM UNITED STATES May, outdoors, relaxing, romantic, shopping, wildlife, popular PREFERENCES: May, outdoors, relaxing, romantic, shopping, wildlife ATTRACTION STYLE: Popular PACE: Medium 3 days in Door County BY A USER FROM UNITED STATES February, outdoors, romantic, beaches, shopping, wildlife, popular PREFERENCES: February, outdoors, romantic, beaches, shopping, wildlife ATTRACTION STYLE: Popular PACE: Medium 5 days in Door County BY A USER FROM UNITED STATES October, outdoors, historic sites, museums, wildlife, popular & hidden gems PREFERENCES: October, outdoors, historic sites, museums, wildlife ATTRACTION STYLE: Popular & hidden gems PACE: Medium 5 days in Door County BY A USER FROM UNITED STATES April, popular PREFERENCES: April ATTRACTION STYLE: Popular PACE: Medium 7 days in Door County BY A USER FROM UNITED STATES June, outdoors, relaxing, romantic, beaches, historic sites, shopping, wildlife, popular PREFERENCES: June, outdoors, relaxing, romantic, beaches, historic sites, shopping, wildlife ATTRACTION STYLE: Popular PACE: Medium 5 days in Door County BY A USER FROM UNITED STATES April, popular PREFERENCES: April ATTRACTION STYLE: Popular PACE: Medium 5 days in Door County BY A USER FROM UNITED STATES April, popular PREFERENCES: April ATTRACTION STYLE: Popular PACE: Medium 10 days in Wisconsin BY A USER FROM SINGAPORE June, teens, kids, slow & easy, hidden gems PREFERENCES: June, teens, kids ATTRACTION STYLE: Hidden gems PACE: Slow & easy 5 days in Door County BY A USER FROM UNITED STATES September, popular PREFERENCES: September ATTRACTION STYLE: Popular PACE: Medium 6 days in Door County BY A USER FROM UNITED STATES July, culture, outdoors, relaxing, beaches, historic sites, museums, shopping, wildlife, popular & hidden gems PREFERENCES: July, culture, outdoors, relaxing, beaches, historic sites, museums, shopping, wildlife ATTRACTION STYLE: Popular & hidden gems PACE: Medium 5 days in Door County BY A USER FROM UNITED STATES April, teens, popular PREFERENCES: April, teens ATTRACTION STYLE: Popular PACE: Medium
View more plans