Trip Planner USA  /  Wisconsin  /  Door County  /  Sister Bay  /  Outdoors  /  Door County Creamery

Door County Creamery, Sister Bay

Categories: Farms, Tourist Spots
Inspirock Rating:
4.6/5 based on 100+ reviews on the web
Door County Creamery is located in Sister Bay. Put Door County Creamery on your schedule, and learn what else deserves a visit by using our Sister Bay vacation builder.
Create a full itinerary - for free!
going to
read all reviews »
  • Nice little place to sample cheese spreads and gelato. Would have loved to have been able to get there everyday. Didn't get a chance to do the wine tasting looked good too! 
  • I tried the Creamery twice this summer, service was slow, food was mediocre compared to similar venues I've visited in the US. Gelato was good, though. 
  • The food was fantastic and we loved the atmosphere, the service was phenomenal. The website is a bit intimidating. 
  • One word that I can sum up my impression to this place, hypocrisy. They made two little goats sitting outside tied with a string, as though they were monkeys in a circus. Hey owner, this scene seems to be pretty sad to me. Also, why did u delete all the negative reviews on ur Instagram page? only the biggest losers would do so. Such a disgrace on such a beautiful, sacred island. Thumb down.
  • The food was delicious! The Door County Creamery definitely takes time to think about each of their food items. The gelato is amazing and the sandwiches are to die for! Also, keeping the baby goats outside is not cruel. It's no different then the goats sitting in a stall in a barn. If anything, it's a great reminder where our food comes from, which is often forgotten.
  • Lots of unique cheese from goats milk. Good wine selections. Very nice and helpful staff.
  • They left two baby goats outside their Sister Bay restaurant for hours. They were left in a very small pin, with a pail of water, for hundereds of people to come by an touch them without any supervision. It was so cruel, and I felt concerned for these goats. They were left there from morning through afternoon (around 2pm), and who knows how much longer they were there after I left. Dont support this cruel business.
  • Outstanding sandwiches, cheeses, and wine. Truly the best food I've found in Door County.
Nearby Attractions
Visit for 1​h 30​m
Visit for 3​h
Visit for 3​h
Visit for 1​h 30​m
Visit for 1​h 30​m
Visit for 1​h 30​m