The Amazing Olive, Port Jefferson

4.8
#6 of 10 in Shopping in Long Island
Find a special ingredient that'll turn an average meal into a culinary delight at The Amazing Olive, a family-owned gourmet shop with a big selection of premium olive oils and balsamic vinegars from around the world. The store also sells salts, herbs, rubs, bath products, gift baskets, and bags. If you're eager to taste your find on the spot, hop to the next-door pasta shop and grab a loaf of garlic bread or slice of cheese you can sprinkle with the oils you bought. Use our Port Jefferson journey builder site to visit The Amazing Olive on your trip to Port Jefferson, and learn what else travelers and our writers recommend seeing nearby.
Create an itinerary including The Amazing Olive
map
The Amazing Olive Reviews
Rate this attraction
TripAdvisor Traveler Rating
TripAdvisor Traveler Rating 5.0
42 reviews
Google
4.8
TripAdvisor
  • Lots of Different vinegar to sample with little pieces of bread. One of the ones I tried was the chocolate vinegar, which was good. Nice little store to browse and sample or buy. The store personnel d...  more »
  • Great selection of oils and vinegars. So many to taste. Also beautiful serving dishes and spices to complement any meal. Friendly and helpful staff.  more »
  • We stumbled upon THE AMAZING OLIVE several years ago and have been hooked ever since!!!! There i are an abundance of olive oil flavors as well as vinegars! We usually buy our favorites and often extra...  more »
Google
  • Best olive oil shop around. Don't confuse Amazing Olive with the recent chain store that opened nearby. Amazing Olive is by far the better quality products and better prices. Staff is super friendly and very knowledgeable, I have to control myself when going in here otherwise I'd spend all my money.
  • The Amazing Olive is a very well organized, beautiful and amazing shop! They have so many options of olive oils, vinegars, soaps, and rubs. I wish I can buy them all! They also ship out orders which is very beneficial. The staff that works there knows a lot about the history of the oils, and vinegars. They are very friendly and sweet once you enter the door. I would recommend going there when you are at Port Jefferson!
  • Just got home with my truffle vinegar and I'm in love. Great Friendly staff. So happy I love close and can go here. Highly recommend to anyone. Great prices too.
  • Love the olive oil and balsamic vinegars (more then 20 varietiesđŸ˜‹ )
  • Love this store! The owners are extremely nice and very knowledgeable. They must have over 60 different oils and vinegars. I brought Chocolate Balsamic vinegar and Jalapeno garlic olive oil.

Plan your trip to Port Jefferson

  • Get a personalized plan

    A complete day-by-day itinerary
    based on your preferences
  • Customize it

    Refine your plan. We'll find the
    best routes and schedules
  • Book it

    Choose from the best hotels
    and activities. Up to 50% off
  • Manage it

    Everything in one place.
    Everyone on the same page.

Where to stay in Port Jefferson

Browse hotels, guesthouses, and unique homes and book your stay on the world's leading accommodation sites.
Live like a local, find unique places to stay
Millions of travel reviews on TripAdvisor

Plans in Port Jefferson by other users

1 day in Port Jefferson BY A USER FROM UNITED STATES February, relaxing, romantic, shopping, popular PREFERENCES: February, relaxing, romantic, shopping ATTRACTION STYLE: Popular PACE: Medium 7 days in United States BY A USER FROM UNITED STATES February, popular PREFERENCES: February ATTRACTION STYLE: Popular PACE: Medium 2 days in Port Jefferson BY A USER FROM UNITED STATES January, relaxing, romantic, historic sites, popular PREFERENCES: January, relaxing, romantic, historic sites ATTRACTION STYLE: Popular PACE: Medium 1 day in Port Jefferson BY A USER FROM UNITED STATES December, popular PREFERENCES: December ATTRACTION STYLE: Popular PACE: Medium 2 days in Port Jefferson BY A USER FROM UNITED STATES October, culture, outdoors, relaxing, beaches, historic sites, shopping, wildlife, popular & hidden gems PREFERENCES: October, culture, outdoors, relaxing, beaches, historic sites, shopping, wildlife ATTRACTION STYLE: Popular & hidden gems PACE: Medium 1 day in Port Jefferson BY A USER FROM UNITED STATES September, popular PREFERENCES: September ATTRACTION STYLE: Popular PACE: Medium 1 day in Port Jefferson BY A USER FROM UNITED STATES August, culture, outdoors, relaxing, beaches, historic sites, museums, shopping, popular PREFERENCES: August, culture, outdoors, relaxing, beaches, historic sites, museums, shopping ATTRACTION STYLE: Popular PACE: Medium 1 day in Port Jefferson BY A USER FROM UNITED STATES September, popular PREFERENCES: September ATTRACTION STYLE: Popular PACE: Medium 4 days in Marion & Port Jefferson BY A USER FROM UNITED STATES June, kids, culture, outdoors, relaxing, historic sites, popular PREFERENCES: June, kids, culture, outdoors, relaxing, historic sites ATTRACTION STYLE: Popular PACE: Medium 1 day in Port Jefferson BY A USER FROM UNITED STATES June, popular PREFERENCES: June ATTRACTION STYLE: Popular PACE: Medium 4 days in Port Jefferson & St. Petersburg BY A USER FROM UNITED STATES April, popular PREFERENCES: April ATTRACTION STYLE: Popular PACE: Medium 36 days in New York State, Grand Canyon National Park & Los Angeles BY A USER FROM AUSTRALIA March, popular PREFERENCES: March ATTRACTION STYLE: Popular PACE: Medium
View more plans