Brown Butter Cookie Company, Cayucos

#2 of 6 in Things to do in Cayucos
Gift & Specialty Shop · Hidden Gem · Shopping
Cayucos open daily 9am-6pm

Paso Robles open daily 11am-6pm Sunday-Thursday 11am-7pm Fridays and Saturdays

San Luis Obispo shop coming fall 2019!

Closed Thanksgiving and Christmas Day
Put Brown Butter Cookie Company on your schedule, and learn what else deserves a visit by using our Cayucos trip planner.
Improve this listing »
Create an itinerary including Brown Butter Cookie Company
© OpenMapTiles © OpenStreetMap contributors

Brown Butter Cookie Company reviews

Rate this attraction
TripAdvisor traveler rating
TripAdvisor traveler rating 4.5
104 reviews
  • Want to know why there is a line to get in this place?? Stop and take a sniff.. Not that sickly sweet cotton candy smell like some chain cookie shops. This is like the grandmas cookie smell of your...  more »
  • Excellent cookies. Well staffed on a busy day. This business provided free samples to help you in your decision making process. Try the honey cookies!  more »
  • We watched as the girls were making the cookies fresh. They were making peanut butter cookies. The place smelled heavenly and the cookies are large. I think the cookies were like $5.00 for 3 big...  more »
  • Omg love this place They hand roll the cookies right in front of you and they are so airy and buttery. My mouth salivates when I think of it. And the samples; yes please and I had to visit more than once before leaving the area. My favorite is the almond flavoured!!
  • Most delicious cookies. Especially the brown butter cocoa sea salt cookies. The main store is amazing and super lovely. As soon as my husband and me entered the store, we felt the love from all the employees immediately. They offered us samples of all the cookies they offer! And wow, I loved that the cookies are Hand and Home made. It makes it even more special. Everyone looked so happy working there in a Group. Alone to visit the store is very interesting. We will return very soon. The small cozy town is very lovely! Thank you for all the samples. Delicious! 🌞
  • One of a kind cookies, all varieties with a distinct & delicious taste. They offer free samples, check business hours, since they close earlier than other places. They also ship but your going to pay more.
  • These are quite possibly the best, "melt-in-your-mouth" cookies that I have ever had. Try the "Original", the Oatmeal Raisin, the Chocolate Chunk... Oh heck, try each and every one!! Delicious!
  • Brown butter in general is a life changer. It has a distinct flavor. I was hoping I was going to get a crispy chewy chocolate Chip cookie made with brown butter. The brown butter cookies are small cookies that crumble in your mouth and leave a floury paste on your tongue. Staff is very friendly. I do recommend the PEANUT BUTTER & SNICKERDOODLE cookies 💛

Plan your trip to Cayucos

  • Get a personalized trip
    A complete day by day itinerary
    based on your preferences
  • Customize it
    Refine your trip. We'll find the
    best routes and schedules
  • Book it
    Choose from the best hotels
    and activities. Up to 50% off
  • Manage it
    Everything in one place.
    Everyone on the same page.