The Little Pie Shack, Fenelon Falls

4.2
#3 of 9 in Things to do in Fenelon Falls
Desert · Hidden Gem · Nature / Park
Create an itinerary including The Little Pie Shack
The Little Pie Shack is located in Fenelon Falls. Add The Little Pie Shack and other attractions to your Fenelon Falls trip itinerary using our Fenelon Falls day trip planning site.
Improve this listing »
Create a full itinerary - for free!

The Little Pie Shack reviews

Rate this attraction
TripAdvisor traveler rating
TripAdvisor traveler rating 4.5
38 reviews
Google
4.3
TripAdvisor
  • Very very expensive. Nice selection of squares. Butter Tarts were too runny and not very full of filling. Regular pies were over $20. 
    Very very expensive. Nice selection of squares. Butter Tarts were too runny and not very full of filling. Regular pies were over $20.  more »
  • Disappointed to say the least. Butter tarts were too runny, crust was very dry and lacking the pecans or raisins in the filling. 
    Disappointed to say the least. Butter tarts were too runny, crust was very dry and lacking the pecans or raisins in the filling.  more »
  • They make a fantastic sandwich. Baked goods are wonderful and they have an assortment of frozen diners Highly recommend 
    They make a fantastic sandwich. Baked goods are wonderful and they have an assortment of frozen diners Highly recommend  more »
Google
  • We bought the 6 pack mix 'n match squares and each one was amazing. Really liked the one called "Mars bar". Staff were friendly and the shop is very cute. I didn't find it all that expensive considering they are high quality "home made" goods and not mass produced. $20 a pie.
  • What happened to the delicious butter tarts you used to make? Bought a six pack this afternoon and I was so disappointed. From the pastry to the filling .... not the same and not nearly as good. Not sure if it was an off day or a new recipe.
  • Great butter tarts, sausage rolls and obviously pies 🥧. Only thing that could make this place better is fresh baked breads
  • I took my family on a “Guess Where Trip” called butter tart trail. The Little Pie Shack was our second stop of the day. Since we were on a butter tart tour I ordered six butter tarts. Two plain..two pecan and two raisin. Since we were in the PIE shack we also bought an apple pie. Our son had two scoops of ice cream. I was so excited to try the butter tarts that when we got back to the car I had to have one. The only issue was they were so fresh that the fill didn’t set up yet. I made a mess but it was worth it delicious. When we got home later in the day I tried a second one and it didn’t disappoint. We’ll try the pie after dinner. We’re from Brampton so I can’t drive up every weekend but I’ll be back for sure.
  • Just like a casino only bring what you want to spend everything awesome

Plan your trip to Fenelon Falls

  • Get a personalized trip
    A full day by day itinerary based on your preferences
  • Customize it
    Refine your trip. We'll find the
    best routes and schedules
  • Book it
    Choose from the best hotels and activities. Up to 50% off
  • Manage it
    Everything in one place. Everyone on the same page.